Health Plan Comparison Calculator

High-deductible plan with an HSA, or a traditional PPO? Enter both plans and your real medical bills to see what each one actually costs after taxes and employer money.

For education only, not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. Results are estimates based on your inputs and assumptions and are not guaranteed. Read the Disclaimer.

1. You

2. The two plans

Plan A: HDHP + HSA

Plan B: Traditional PPO

3. Your medical expenses

Add rows, or upload a CSV with columns description, category, amount (date optional). Categories: medical, Rx, dental, vision. In Excel or Numbers, use File → Save As / Export → CSV. Download sample template

DateDescriptionCategoryAmount ($)

4. Results

Plan A net cost$0
Plan B net cost$0
Item (per year)Plan A: HDHP + HSAPlan B: PPO

5. HSA: spend it vs. invest it

YearSpend it (cash, 0%)Invest it (pay bills out of pocket, keep receipts)

How the math works: medical and Rx costs apply to the deductible, then coinsurance, capped at the out-of-pocket max; copays are added and also capped. Dental and vision aren't covered by either medical plan, so they're paid from a Limited-Purpose FSA (Plan A) or health FSA (Plan B) if you use one. FSA money you don't spend is counted as lost (some plans allow a carryover of up to $680). HSA tax savings use your federal, state and (optionally) FICA rates; some states, such as California and New Jersey, tax HSA contributions. Premiums are assumed to be paid pre-tax under both plans. Leftover HSA money stays yours and isn't counted as a cost.

For education only, not personalized tax, insurance or investment advice. Check your plan documents and a tax professional before you decide. Your data stays in your browser.